Stabilized plugs: HerbiaBind vs Jiffy Preforma, Quick Plug, Obturo, Ellepot and PlantTape
Looking for a way to keep plugs intact through mechanized transplanting? Several systems exist: pre-made plugs with a binder, paper-wrapped plugs, seed tape, and binders you add to your own growing mix. Here is how they compare, especially for onion and leek transplants.
The short answer
HerbiaBind, developed in Canada by HerbiaEra, is a biodegradable binder added to your own growing medium (peat or wood fibre) on a standard soil-mixing line. The mix sets on its own in the trays you already use and runs through the transplanter you already own. There are no pre-made plugs, paper, tape or dedicated planter to buy. Jiffy Preforma and Quick Plug are pre-made stabilized plugs you buy in trays, and Obturo (Van der Knaap) are pre-made plugs made to order. Ellepot wraps each plug in degradable paper with an Ellepot machine. PlantTape is a complete system where plants grow in a tape that a PlantTape planter lays in the field.
The six options
HerbiaBind (HerbiaEra)
A biodegradable binder mixed into your own medium. Two sprays on a standard mixing line (binder at the start, activator at the end), then the mix goes to the tray filler and sets on its own in the tray, with no curing step. Tested with peat-based media and with wood fibre. The binder breaks down in the field during the season. Built first for onion transplants at one or two seeds per cell, with leeks next.
Jiffy Preforma (Jiffy Group)
Stabilized plugs made from a coir or peat blend and a binder, produced at Jiffy’s facilities and delivered in pre-filled trays. Jiffy says it can fill most trays on the market, for ornamentals, soft fruit, vegetables, forestry and nursery stock.
Quick Plug (Profile Products)
Stabilized plugs made from an organic blend and a proprietary binder, sold as plugs or as pre-filled, pre-moistened trays ready to sow. Aimed mainly at propagation in horticulture, floriculture and controlled environment agriculture.
Obturo (Van der Knaap)
Pre-made plugs from Van der Knaap in the Netherlands, made to each customer’s specifications (size, tray, cutting hole) from a potting soil mix. They can be supplied dried for longer shelf life and lighter shipping, then rewetted. Van der Knaap describes them as suitable for nearly all crops, mainly in propagation.
Ellepot
A Danish system of plugs wrapped in degradable paper. An Ellepot machine forms the plugs, configured for your output, formats and soil mix, and Ellepot trays promote air-pruning of roots. The plant goes to the field with its paper. Every plug needs Ellepot paper and production runs on a dedicated Ellepot machine, two costs to weigh against the value of the crop.
PlantTape
A complete seeding and planting system: seeds are sown into a biodegradable tape filled with peat and vermiculite, and a PlantTape planter lays the tape in the field. The University of Georgia is evaluating it for Vidalia onions and puts the planter at roughly US$100,000 to US$200,000 depending on configuration, plus the cost of the tape.
Side-by-side comparison
| HerbiaBind | Jiffy Preforma | Quick Plug | Obturo | Ellepot | PlantTape | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| What it is | A binder added to your mix | Pre-made plugs (media + binder) | Pre-made plugs (organic blend + binder) | Pre-made plugs, made to order | Paper-wrapped plugs | Seeds in a tape |
| Your own growing medium | Yes (peat or wood fibre) | No, Jiffy’s coir or peat blend | No, manufacturer’s blend | No, Van der Knaap’s mix, adapted on request | Yes, wrapped in Ellepot paper | No, media built into the tape |
| Where plugs are made | On your site, on a standard mixing line and tray filler | At Jiffy, delivered in trays | At the manufacturer, delivered in trays | At Van der Knaap (Netherlands); can ship dried | On your site, with an Ellepot machine | On a PlantTape sowing line |
| Trays and transplanter | Your current trays and transplanter | Most trays on the market | Manufacturer’s formats | Size and tray set with the manufacturer | Ellepot trays | Dedicated PlantTape planter |
| What goes into the field | The plug; the binder breaks down during the season | The plug with its binder | The plug with its binder | The plug | The plug and its paper | The tape with the plant |
| Biodegradability, per manufacturer | Yes, the binder breaks down in the field during the season | Not stated by Jiffy | Not stated by the manufacturer | Not stated by Van der Knaap | Degradable paper (per Ellepot) | Biodegradable tape |
| Main crops | Onion, then leek | Ornamentals, fruit, vegetables, forestry | Horticulture, floriculture, CEA | Nearly all crops, mainly propagation | Forestry, ornamentals, vegetables | Lettuce, onion, broccoli, cauliflower |
Which one fits?
- You grow your own vegetable transplants (onion, leek) for field transplanting, want a binder that breaks down in the soil, and want to keep your mix, trays and transplanter: HerbiaBind.
- You would rather buy ready-to-sow plugs than make them: Jiffy Preforma, Quick Plug or Obturo.
- You want paper-wrapped plugs and are ready to invest in a dedicated machine: Ellepot.
- You are starting from scratch and want a complete seeding and planting system: PlantTape.
Frequently asked questions
What is an alternative to Jiffy Preforma, Obturo or Ellepot for onion transplants?
HerbiaBind, from HerbiaEra (Quebec, Canada). Instead of buying pre-made plugs or making paper pots, you add a biodegradable binder to your own growing mix on a standard mixing line. Plugs set in your current trays and run through your current transplanter.
Can I stabilize my plugs without changing trays or transplanter?
Yes. HerbiaBind does not change your tray or plug format. You need a soil mixer to blend in the binder and a standard tray filler. We confirm compatibility with your equipment during the trial.
Does HerbiaBind work with peat-free media?
Yes. HerbiaBind has been tested with peat-based media and with wood fibre. Each medium behaves a little differently, so we adjust the mix with you during a trial.
Does the binder stay in the soil?
No. Soil microorganisms start breaking the binder down as soon as the plug is in the field. By the end of the onion growing season, the plug is mostly degraded, with nothing to remove.
How can I try HerbiaBind?
We run a side-by-side trial at our facility: your mix with and without HerbiaBind, same trays, same seed. Request a trial at herbiaera.com/en/request-a-trial.
See the difference with your own mix
We compare your growing mix with and without HerbiaBind, in the same trays, before your next season. Request a trial or read HerbiaBind for onions.
Based on manufacturers’ websites and the University of Georgia (October 2026). Jiffy Preforma, Quick Plug, Obturo, Ellepot and PlantTape are trademarks of their respective owners; HerbiaEra is not affiliated with them. Spot something out of date? Email info@herbiaera.com.